What is Right of First Refusal in Custody Cases

There is no doubt that parents are the major influencers of a child’s behavior and way of thinking. Parents have the ability to shape their children’s personalities by spending as much time as possible with them.

While that sounds self-evident, a divorce can impede the parent/child relationship. It is incumbent upon both parents to help the children thrive following a divorce, which means spending as much time as possible with them. The parents may be separated, but the children and parents are still one unit. That is where the right of first refusal becomes important.

Right of first refusal in child custody agreements refers to the fact that one parent must first offer the other parent the opportunity to look after their children before contacting a babysitter or another family member to care for the kids. It is a clause that many non-custodial parents want to be included in the divorce agreement to be able to spend extra time with the kids.

What is the Right of First Refusal Relative to Custody Issues?

In any divorce involving children, the parents will agree to a custody agreement that is enforceable by the court. Each parent is allocated a specific amount of time with the children. Sometimes, it is a 50-50 arrangement. In other cases, there will be a custodial parent who has physical custody of the children the majority of the time.

The right of first refusal states that if the custodial parent is unable to look after the children, for whatever reason, he or she must give the non-custodial parent the first chance to have the children during this period. Only if the non-custodial parent refuses can the custodial parent get a babysitter or other caretaker for the children.

The purpose is to provide greater flexibility in custody issues. For example, if the custodial parent has long working hours – either permanently or temporarily, and if the non-custodial parent is available, the non-custodial parent can insist that the children be in his or her custody for this time period, even if he or she is not scheduled for visitation rights.

The right of first refusal also applies to more spontaneous moments. If the custodial parent makes a spur-of-the-moment decision to spend a few hours with friends, he or she cannot simply ask a neighbor to watch the children. Instead, said parent must give the non-custodial parent the right of first refusal to spend time with the children before asking anyone else. Only if the non-custodial parent refuses can the custodial parent make other arrangements.

The right of first refusal helps parents spend as much time as possible with their children before involving a third party, such as a babysitter.

Problems with Right of First Refusal?

The right of first refusal ensures that the interests of the child are put first. While most parents agree that is a good idea, it may be difficult for two people to communicate amicably and reasonably following a bitter divorce. It can bring up all types of old issues. For example, if the mother wants to see friends and asks her ex if he would like to watch the children for a few hours, the situation can turn into a repeat of past arguments, with him accusing her of never spending enough time with the children. Or if the non-custodial father refuses the offer because he has a date, it could explode into accusations of past misconduct.

Such arguments are a no-win for everyone concerned.

How to Avoid Arguing over the Right of First Refusal

Some arguments can be avoided if both exes make an effort to keep the other informed of important plans while using a parenting schedule to keep each other up to date on the children’s activities. For example, while noting a doctor’s appointment on the parenting schedule, a custodial parent can add, “I am considering plans for that evening. Do you want to take Johnny for the night? Please let me know by the weekend.” It is a good idea to request a specific deadline to avoid a vague answer such as, “I am not sure yet.”

This keeps communication more open and fluid and can reduce conflict between the parents. The non-custodial parent can accept or refuse the offer, and the custodial parent has time to make other arrangements.

Conclusion

While the right of first refusal clause benefits the children in most instances, it is not a good idea if the custodial parent suspects mistreatment or abuse of the children.

Also, divorce agreements can be amended post-divorce if it wasn’t initially included. A non-custodial parent has the right to change his or her mind and petition the court for a right-of-refusal clause after the divorce has become final.

The legal process can get difficult, which is why we always recommend that you seek the assistance of counsel; or at least have a consultation. Schedule a consultation with one of our attorneys today to review the issues of your case, the legal options you may have, and certain rights that pertain to your unique situation.

Have more questions? Let us know by sending an email to: questions@legallotus.com and we will do our best to develop content to provide you with direction and insight!

For more information:
Check out and subscribe to our YouTube Channel
Follow us on Instagram
Like us on Facebook
Visit our website
Shop our Legal Templates

No Attorney-Client Relationship or Legal Advice: Communication of information by, in, to or through this Website and your receipt or use of it: (1) is not provided in the course of and does not create or constitute an attorney-client relationship; (2) is not intended as a solicitation; (3) is not intended to convey or constitute legal advice; and (4) is not a substitute for obtaining legal advice from a qualified attorney. You should not act upon any such information without first seeking qualified professional counsel on you specific matter. The hiring of an attorney is an important decision that should not be based solely upon Web site communications or advertisements. Feel free to contact us if you need legal assistance.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: